Supposing a = 1, b = 1
(1) a = b
(2) a×a = a×b
(3) a×a - b×b = a×b - b×b
(4) a×a + a×b - a×b - b×b = b×( a-b )
(5) a×( a+b ) - b×( a+b ) = b×( a-b )
(6) ( a+b )×( a-b ) = b×( a-b )
(7) a+b = b
(8) 2 = 1
Where is the mistake ?
(1) a = b
(2) a×a = a×b
(3) a×a - b×b = a×b - b×b
(4) a×a + a×b - a×b - b×b = b×( a-b )
(5) a×( a+b ) - b×( a+b ) = b×( a-b )
(6) ( a+b )×( a-b ) = b×( a-b )
(7) a+b = b
(8) 2 = 1
Where is the mistake ?
-
You cannot go from step 6 to 7 because you are dividing both sides by zero...
a-b=0, so if you divide both sides by a-b, you are dividing both sides by zero, which is impossible.
a-b=0, so if you divide both sides by a-b, you are dividing both sides by zero, which is impossible.
-
The mistake is in step 6.
(6) ( a+b )×( a-b ) = b×( a-b )
If you expand the LHS ( a+b )×( a-b ), you get a^2 - b^2 (a squared minus b squared), which is different from your RHS.
(6) ( a+b )×( a-b ) = b×( a-b )
If you expand the LHS ( a+b )×( a-b ), you get a^2 - b^2 (a squared minus b squared), which is different from your RHS.
-
Hello.
The mistake lies in going from line 6 to line 7. You cannot divide out the a-b in this problem. If a=b, then a-b=0, and so, you are dividing by 0. We know division by 0 is quite illegal.
The mistake lies in going from line 6 to line 7. You cannot divide out the a-b in this problem. If a=b, then a-b=0, and so, you are dividing by 0. We know division by 0 is quite illegal.
-
Division by (a -- b) is not allowed as a = 1, b = 1 makes (a -- b) = 0.
-
The mistake is in step (6).Since a=b=1 then a-b=0.You can't divide by 0.
Step 7 is invalid
Step 7 is invalid