Will science ever be able to give us an answer "how did it all begin"?
Before big bang. Or there is no answer? Then what are we? Real or what?
-------------------------------------------------------
answers:
TheAsender say: science is an ever changing field of study with today's firm beliefs gone tomorrow, so I would say NO
-
Const. King say: No, only Hillary has that answer.
-
Ruel The Midianite say: Maybe. We are definitely lacking a good theory of strong quantum gravity. When such a theory is eventually developed, there may be progress.
-
John A. Deering say: Energy was there. According to quantum science today the universe is full of energy which by definition cannot come from nothing.
-
aladdinwa say: I don't know. But, does that mean we should give up on trying to find the answer? If we had done that, earthquakes and comets would still be signs from God.
-
Manuel say: As far as I can tell we are real, how did it all begin is … difficult.
-
Jeffrey K say: Quantum Gravity Theory might explain how and why the Big Bang happened. Our concept of time breaks down at times before Plank Time 10^-43 sec. We don't know what replaces time. But when we do, we will have a better understanding of the beginning.
-
John say: If we could see the forest then maybe we could. Alas, we can only see the trees.
-
goring say: We are real.
The Biblical record of Creation indicates that there is a beginning Just as it described it.
-
Ronald 7 say: One thing is clear that none of us were there anyway
All we can do is Guess
That is where Theories come in
Many argue that Theories are not the actual truth
No Wonder Religion comes into it
It is a very handy way of explaining it
Especially when all there was to begin with was Darkness, then there was Light
White Hole, a theory, but it could work
Nobody really knows what goes on inside Black Holes Physically or Mathematically
We can wrack our brains all night
I say it was a Quark of Nature
And I am heading down to the Pub
-
Eric say: We know how it all began. The Creator(s) created everything. Who created HIM/HER/IT/THEM? That, we don't know.
-
Mark say: Before the Big Bang there was nothing but this huge clump of energy. Hot, intense, unstable energy mass composed of neutrons, electrons, and protons and atoms. It was a white glowing mass. One day it just happen to get so hot and unstable it just collapsed under it's own pressure and exploded, created everything we know and us.
-
vic say: The answer is easy and in the Bible, yhere was nothing then God said let there be light, which I think was the Big Bang
-
thegreatone say: People don't have an answer, and the answer is, there was nothing before the big bang, at the same time.
What I've always heard was that there was one single nucleus just out there, wherever, and then due to physics, the big bang happened. That's what I've always heard. But, no one ever said where the nucleus came from. Nor, how physics just all of a sudden started happening from just one nucleus.
-
gregory_dittman say: There are two popular theories right now with one being tested. The one being tested is the idea that two dimensions rubbed against each other causing friction which created the energy that formed our universe. Once out universe gets so spread out, the process is most likely going to happen again and a new universe will be created. To test this idea, it is generally believed that gravity waves were created and those gravity waves would physically move the background radiation around like a foot on sand. A satellite was sent into space to detect these imprints.
-
John say: Only if you can answer the question "where do cute girls come from". Yum yum smack smack..
-
say: With the Christian religion, scientists can simply read the first few sentences of a Book and they can know the answer to "how did it all begin", that's the greatest Spoiler ever.
However, most scientists will come to the conclusion that "Earth started with the Big bang, the big bang created the universe" is a valid answer, which sounds way crazier than "In the beginning, God said let there be light", we cannot explain it, it's just part of our History and that's something we'd ought to accept.
-
Donut Tim say: It is doubtful.
There is no evidence for or against the universe having an infinitely long past. Physicists and philosophers remain unsure about what, if anything preceded the Big Bang. Many refuse to speculate, doubting that information from any such prior state could ever be accessible.
(One should not confuse a possible origin of the universe with the big bang. The big bang is the “expansion” of the universe and is still visibly in progress. Evidence indicates that the present expansion had a start. Sometimes the phrase big bang is used to mean the “start” of the expansion.)
-
quantumclaustrophobe say: It may not be possible to deduce how it started.... But we shouldn't stop trying.
-
Bill say: I don't know if science will ever find what was before the big bang, but that doesn't make us any less real right now.
-
rennhackrobert say: Sure as soon as atheists rule
-
say: Unless "science" recognizes what's in the Bible, no.
-
nick say: no idea
-
Dixon say: I suspect the question will continue to be asked and successfully answered but "it" will keep changing.
-
sparrow say: Yes. We're real. The best theories so far say that everything is made from energy fields.
Even solid matter is made from stabilized energy. The question is, where did all the energy
come from. Also, there's more. Everything is in a constant state of losing energy, of winding
down. And eventually, the heat death of the Universe, where nothing is moving anymore.
Technical terms are; thermodynamic equilibrium and maximum entropy.
-
stephen say: On your headline question - science began with observation and later experimentation. I'll leave the 2nd sub- part of the question to others
-
noname say: fdzfv
-
Climate Realist say: I don't know.
The primordial Universe, especially in its first few seconds, had conditions that could never be created in a lab.
Note, that "How did it all begin?" is a separate question from "Is there a God?" Atheists and creationists both fail to recognize this distinction.
-
y say: bubbles
-
my say: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dQw4w9WgXcQ
-
oneofmagi@rocketmail.com say: Before begining, God was.
-
HC say: Absolutely, yes.
The question can be rephrased as 'What is Ultimate Reality', and answers are already taking shape. Bear in mind that our science is only about 300 years old, give or take, yet we have made huge strides towards an in-depth understanding within that time, despite both our limited IQ, and the limits of science itself.
-
great knight say: "Who hath measured the waters in the hollow of his hand, and meted out heaven with the span, and comprehended the dust of the earth in a measure, and weighed the mountains in scales, and the hills in a balance?"- Isaiah chapter 40 verse 12.
"Hast thou not known? hast thou not heard, that the everlasting God, the LORD, the Creator of the ends of the earth, fainteth not, neither is weary? there is no searching of his understanding.
He giveth power to the faint; and to them that have no might he increaseth strength.
Even the youths shall faint and be weary, and the young men shall utterly fall:
But they that wait upon the LORD shall renew their strength; they shall mount up with wings as eagles; they shall run, and not be weary; and they shall walk, and not faint."- Isaiah chapter 40 verses 28 to 31.
Believe in Jesus Christ and you shall have everlasting life! Get a king james bible and believe.
Read Matthew.
Read 1 John ch. 4.
https://youtu.be/vw-6ToEcirE
https://youtu.be/sYFA0Zc8DA4
-
Aditi say: We are all real and already science has given how humans actually get developed and updated as humans were initially an animal.
And still I believe that scientists will soon prove that as nothing has hide to them even if it takes time.
-
drake say: Many scientists say the Big Bang is the origin of all of time.
-
NONAME say: even in the distant future I dont think there is an answer...I mean there is not a knowable answer...It was an act of creation...that is the scientific definition of it..I am not religious but what else could you call it? it was not a bang...it defies all laws of the universe and even our minds
-
Who say: there will be many theories as to the "how" - problem is - how you gonna prove with is the correct one?
"before" is meaningless - our "time " started when this universe came to exist
we have no idea if "time" existed "before" it did - if not then "before" has no meaning
(the often used analogy is - asking what was "before" is like asking what is north of the north pole)
-
CarolOklaNola say: We may never figure out what there was before the Big Bang. We very definitely are real. I almost impaled my thumb with an insulin needle this morning, and one my cats claws and teeth were another reminder I am real.
-
Gerald say: I doubt we will reach the end of this century this cannot continue
-
Nibiru say: it is possible.
stars are the furnaces that create the atoms that make the planets and everything on them.
-
Acetek say: Maybe in the far distant future.
-