Atheists; two questions for you?

I have a large Folgers coffee can full of change; which I toss in the can every time I return home from a store; and every few years take it to a coinstar machine when it fills.

Suppose that for a minute I violated God's law and actually brought an atheist into my home.

I show the atheist this large coffee can filled with change. I then tell him to step outside for a moment. When I bring him back into my house; he sees that all the change is now spread out all over the floor.

I ask him to examine the change and ask if he notices anything unusual about the coins. He says "Yes; all the coins are facing heads up."

I say "Do you know how these coins came to be this way?"

Now; do you think he is going to say:

A. "You betcha! CLEARLY you just flung that coffee can right up in the air; and they just randomly landed by that! Boy oh boy what are the odds of THAT!"

Or do you think he'll say:

B. "It's because you took the time to create the pattern and set them up that way?"

Second question: Mathematically speaking; Where do you put the odds of the Big Bang just happening; and all of creation just forming like that; compared with the mathematical odds that all the coins would land that way randomly?