Let p,q be two polynomial functions. Show that the function:
1/x
cannot be the derivative
f(x)=p(x)/q(x)
Please, do not use integral operator, thanks :)
......................................…
I think that I can work on the polunomials degree but I don't know how.
1/x
cannot be the derivative
f(x)=p(x)/q(x)
Please, do not use integral operator, thanks :)
......................................…
I think that I can work on the polunomials degree but I don't know how.
-
Suppose that there exist (nonzero) polynomials p(x), q(x) such that
(d/dx) p(x)/q(x) = 1/x.
Expanding, we have
[p'(x) q(x) - p(x) q'(x)] / [q(x)]^2 = 1/x.
==> x [p'(x) q(x) - p(x) q'(x)] = [q(x)]^2.
Now, let deg p(x) = n and deg q(x) = m.
[We can assume that m, n > 1, since otherwise we can get quick contradictions.
Plainly, q(x) can not be constant, because the derivative of a polynomial is also a polynomial.
Moreover, p(x) can not be constant, because otherwise (say p(x) = c) we then have
-cx q'(x) = [q(x)]^2. Comparing degrees, we have m - 1 = 2m ==> m = -1, which is not possible for the degree of a polynomial.]
-----
Now, we compute degrees.
deg [p'(x) q(x) - p(x) q'(x)] = m + n - 1.
==> deg (x[p'(x) q(x) - p(x) q'(x)]) = m + n.
deg (q(x))^2 = 2m.
Hence, m + n = 2m ==> m = n.
-------------
So, we can write (for some constants a(i) and b(i))
p(x) = a(n) x^n + a(n-1) x^(n-1) + ... + a(0) and p(x) = b(n) x^n + b(n-1) x^(n-1) + ... + b(0).
Substituting this into p'(x) q(x) - p(x) q'(x), we find that the highest degree terms (2n-1) cancel each other out (try writing these terms out).
Hence, deg[p'(x) q(x) - p(x) q'(x)] < 2n - 1.
==> deg(x [p'(x) q(x) - p(x) q'(x)]) < 2n, which is a contradiction.
----------------
So, no such rational function exists.
I hope this helps!
(d/dx) p(x)/q(x) = 1/x.
Expanding, we have
[p'(x) q(x) - p(x) q'(x)] / [q(x)]^2 = 1/x.
==> x [p'(x) q(x) - p(x) q'(x)] = [q(x)]^2.
Now, let deg p(x) = n and deg q(x) = m.
[We can assume that m, n > 1, since otherwise we can get quick contradictions.
Plainly, q(x) can not be constant, because the derivative of a polynomial is also a polynomial.
Moreover, p(x) can not be constant, because otherwise (say p(x) = c) we then have
-cx q'(x) = [q(x)]^2. Comparing degrees, we have m - 1 = 2m ==> m = -1, which is not possible for the degree of a polynomial.]
-----
Now, we compute degrees.
deg [p'(x) q(x) - p(x) q'(x)] = m + n - 1.
==> deg (x[p'(x) q(x) - p(x) q'(x)]) = m + n.
deg (q(x))^2 = 2m.
Hence, m + n = 2m ==> m = n.
-------------
So, we can write (for some constants a(i) and b(i))
p(x) = a(n) x^n + a(n-1) x^(n-1) + ... + a(0) and p(x) = b(n) x^n + b(n-1) x^(n-1) + ... + b(0).
Substituting this into p'(x) q(x) - p(x) q'(x), we find that the highest degree terms (2n-1) cancel each other out (try writing these terms out).
Hence, deg[p'(x) q(x) - p(x) q'(x)] < 2n - 1.
==> deg(x [p'(x) q(x) - p(x) q'(x)]) < 2n, which is a contradiction.
----------------
So, no such rational function exists.
I hope this helps!